Jewish State | Daniel Gordis - Dispatches from an Anxious State

Tag: jewish state

The Nation-State Called Israel – Key to the “Chosen People”?, Portland, November 2009

Nation States

It’s a new world, Bibi

The Jerusalem Post Internet Edition

Jul. 2, 2009 Daniel Gordis , THE JERUSALEM POST I wouldn't be surprised if Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu were thinking of Tevye these days. Tevye was, after all, a quasi-pathetic character simply trying to make sense of a world changing far more quickly than he might have ever imagined possible. Having granted his daughter, Hodel, permission to marry Perchik the pauper, he wonders, "What am I going to tell your mother?" He didn't choose Perchik, and he doesn't really approve. But he is powerless. And when his wife expresses her dismay, the best explanation he can offer is "It's a new world, Golde." "It's a new ...

Protecting the Zionist Narrative, At Last

nakba60In Perspective: Protecting the Zionist narrative at last Jun. 4, 2009 Daniel Gordis , THE JERUSALEM POST Imagine that Germany, embittered by incessant reminders of what happened during the Holocaust, passed a law forbidding German Jews from publicly marking the destruction of European Jewry. Or that the US Congress, tired of hearing Native Americans recite their tales of woe, made it illegal for them to mention their losses on July 4. If Turkey passed legislation like that, directed at Armenian memories of 1915, we would hardly blink an eye. But if a genuine democracy followed suit? We would scarcely believe our ears. So why are we not more distressed by legislation before the Knesset that would criminalize marking the "Nakba" ...

Israel’s Holocaust ‘Obsession’? — A Radio “Debate” With Avrum Burg

avrum-burgInterfaith Radio (http://interfaithradio.org) recently interviewed Avrum Burg, former speaker of the Knesset, on his recent controversial book.  They then interviewed me for an alternate perspective.  The interview (along with an audio file that can be downloaded) is available at http://interfaithradio.org/node/892.  Burg's interview begins at 22 min 56 sec, while the segment with me begins at 37 min 12 sec. In a controversial new book, Avraham Burg argues that Israel is “stuck in Auschwitz,” using the Holocaust as the defining experience of Jewish identity. This former speaker of the Israeli Parliament says his country's preoccupation has led to an unhealthy nationalism that mourns the past, fears the future and feeds violence. Daniel ...

For the Sake of Clarity – A Thought Experiment

securityfenceIn Perspective: For the sake of clarity, a thought experiment May. 14, 2009 Daniel Gordis , THE JERUSALEM POST He was in his 20s, the young man with the question after my lecture. He couldn't have asked it more kindly or gently. Without a hint of cynicism or anger, he expressed what was clearly on the minds of many of the people his age in the crowd: "Can you justify a Jewish state," he wanted to know, "when having a Jewish state means giving up on so many of Judaism's values?" Here's what he didn't say: Israel is the root of evil in the Middle East. It's the cause of checkpoints, of roadblocks, of a big ugly wall that runs ...